The looming question around “Werewolf” is a supernatural one – Is Cal Blaine actually a werewolf? Keegan Lounsberry, an actor just a few years out of the woods of the adolescent crises his character faces, handles this two-fold idea with acumen. He has to balance the belief that Cal actually is a werewolf with the reason he needs to believe in the fantasy, all the while keeping his long curly hair out of his eyes. He connects with Mark Austin as his teacher Mr. Alessandro truthfully, even if his longer monologues cross into territory eerier than a werewolf’s lair – Lounsberry doesn’t seem to need to blink.
Austin’s challenges stemmed more from the play’s structure than from acting difficulty – he has to be on stage with himself, 30 years older. The play blends the past and present, an older Mr. Alessandro telling his role in Cal’s story through the eyes of a younger Alessandro. Tom Minion plays the older Alessandro and with Austin successfully creates a man unable to forget the poor boy-wolf who couldn’t get over his past. While both Austin and Minion gave Alessandro the energy and care of a great teacher, it’s really Fonte’s script that allows them to give the character a full mythology. From the relationship with Alessandro’s wife, to the occasional throb from a “dog’s” bite, Fonte includes such specific details that Alessandro could be a long-time friend.
The play loses momentum after intermission, however, when the older Alessandro meets another troubled student, a black baby-Daddy whose sole purpose seems to be modernizing the plot. The playwright’s inclination is a good one; the incident allows the audience to understand what Alessandro thought he did wrong with Cal. But Jeffrey Owens as Tequan Adkins lisps expressionlessly through the powerful dialogue, a harrowing story of a dysfunctional family with drug ties, seeming to disregard the emotional weight of his role. He crosses his arms around the over-sized thug sweatshirt, paces in a circle and ends up feeling more superfluous than illuminating.
Had the first act been a play on it’s own, Fonte could be praised and Rarely Done lauded for choosing something to both celebrate the Halloween season and comment on a serious topic like mental illness in those who have experienced trauma. Fonte untangles the facts of Cal’s life one at a time, tossing out his bait and reeling the audience in like a willing fish. But the key player in this production’s second act left much – like diction – to be desired.