Somewhere in Pennsylvania there has to be a Pittsburgh Pirates fan that would sell his soul to the devil for a winning season. He might be middle-aged, middle-mangement real estate salesman living in the suburbs with his wife. From the outside, it might seem like the American dream - almost.
The Cortland Repertory Theater proves that the American love for baseball has changed little over the course of a century in their current production of the 1950s musical "Damn Yankees."
Joe Boyd (Jef Canter) a man very much like that Pirates fan, says "hell" so much during a poorly played Washington Senator's game that the devil himself shows up to offer him a deal: to leave his wife and become 22-year-old Joe Hardy, star baseball player from nowhere.
He takes it.
Canter sings well as Boyd, channelling a Willy Loman-like despair, especially into his interactions with his ignored wife Meg, played sweetly by Erica Livingston. But the best moment for Boyd is his change into Hardy, a truly surprising moment on stage when Canter walks out a door only for his Superman counterpart, played by Peter Carrier, to walk in.
Carrier can do no wrong as a singer, confidently grasping notes others might reach for and offering tenderness as well as power; "A Man Doesn't Know" is particularly touching. Still, Hardy isn't the deepest of characters and though Carrier's vocal talent is evident, his abs might be more memorable than his A's.
Alyson Tolbert, playing the scantily clad Lola, might have a similar problem. Her miles-long legs stretched to the ceiling say more than any line she sings - they scream that she's a dancer who doesn't get a chance to bust a move. Such is the almost stagnant nature of several dance numbers, with the exception of "Shoeless Joe" danced with footlights-to-spotlights energy by Megan Rozak as journalist Gloria Thorpe.
Tolbert did redeem a lackluster "A Little Brains, A Little Talent" in the second act with "Who's Got the Pain" in part because of a number of talented male dancers, dance captain Jared Titus and the soon-to-be-on-Broadway Gerald Avery (He starts in "Spiderman" in just a few weeks) particularly. Her scenes with standout Dominick Varney are equally as charming.
As Applegate - the devil - Varney comes across more mischievous than sinister and he makes it work as the show needs a little comedy amidst all of Joe Hardy's moral dilemmas: Does he go back to his wife? Or should he remain a big baseball star?
However, much of the fun of "Damn Yankees" comes from the supporting players: The Senators.
The team functions as a character all its own - a rambunctious, sometimes partially dressed character. Each of the men's ensemble add something remarkable to the performance simply by doing their work as actors. They appear united, a team through and through, but each, if you watch closely, has given himself over to a unique character that has a moment to shine with each choreographic shift or new song. Nathan Norrington's enormous grin, Robert Conte's endearing bumbling and Kristopher Dean's adorable slides through the crowd of men's legs continually brighten a sometimes moody show. And their singing ain't too bad either. "Heart," their inspirational number right at the beginning, comes across sincere, rather than corny. As I met the gentlemen portraying the Senators, I think a lot of that comes from the performers themselves bringing joy to the stage and each other, not just the script calling for jolly good guys.
"Damn Yankees" has got heart, in 1953 and in 2009. It both condemns and glorifies the life of the average American - but even that analysis might be too serious for a show just right for the season and just right for CRT. Guaranteed, you'll leave smiling.